The Men’s Attitude is reader-supported! We might get a small commission if you purchase something after clicking our links, at no extra charge for you.
Before you go and take the butter out of the fridge and start applying it to your beard, take a few minutes to read this post and learn everything you need to know about these beard care products. Beard butter can be a great remedy for itchy beards and sensitive skin.
There is a lot of hype with each of these beard care products. You might not be experienced, but we are going to compare each of them side-by-side so that you can take a look at the comparison to see the pros and cons of each one.
The really amazing thing about them is that they are good for many different types of skin types. They are crafted with natural ingredients to provide you with a creamy texture formula that can directly treat dry beard conditions and itchy skin. Keep reading and find out the best beard butter.
A Quick Glance at the Top 3 Beard Butters
Wild Willie’s Beard Butter
Wild Willie’s Beard Butter is 100% natural and is made in the USA. The hold is amazing, but it is a bit difficult to work it.
Grave Before Shave Cigar Blend Beard Butter
Grave Before Shave Cigar Blend is another beard butter that is made in the USA. It has a really nice pleasant smell, and it is good for styling. On the other hand, it is a bit pricey, but we think it is worth it.
Maestro’s Classic Mark of a Man
Maestro’s Classic Mark of a Man is affordable. It is water-based, contains natural ingredients, and is an unscented beard butter.
What Is Beard Butter?
Beard butter is a butter-based beard product designed to moisturize the skin under the beard. It can also help you shape your beard and look shinier and healthier. Many beard care products within this industry have deep conditioner properties that can be used to form different styles and ultimately groom your beard into the perfect one.
The four main ingredients of beard butter are butter (not the dairy one in your fridge!!), carrier oils, essential oils, and beeswax. Additional ingredients in premium beard butter include black pepper and fruit extracts.
What to Look for When Buying A Beard Butter
This is by far the most important factor when buying beard butter. You should always look for products that utilize 100% natural ingredients and avoid the ones that have artificial scents or preservatives.
After purchasing an all-natural beard butter brand, you have to consider your personal preferences. What type of skin do you have, and which carrier oil will benefit you most? What kind of scent do you prefer? Do you want a mild scent, a clean scent, or a strong scent? Which essential oil has this scent?
After you have decided on the ingredients you like, you will probably have a list of potential purchases with different prices. At this point, you have to think about the benefits you will get if you buy a more expensive butter. And ask yourself the questions below.
- Will it last longer?
- Can I find the same ingredients in a cheaper butter?
- Am I paying the brand name?
Everyone buys beard conditioning products for different reasons. You need to understand why you want to buy a beard butter product and try to determine what your expectations are.
- Do you have dry skin and want a butter that will help you moisturize it?
- Do you want it for styling purposes?
- Do you want just something to help your facial hair texture?
- Do you have a coarse beard?
Whatever your goals may be, you should read about the ingredients and decide which product will help you achieve your goals.
So, what should you buy, balm or butter? Well, that depends on your personal desire. The butter utter has nourishing effects, while beard balm will help you to style your beard and manage flyaway hairs thanks to its bigger concentration of wax.
At last, the balm is a bit more difficult to manage as it is harder and needs more working with your fingers to make it workable, so many new guys prefer to stick to butter. If you decide to go with balm, read our complete guide about the best beard balms on the market.
Top 5 Beard Butters
1. Wild Willie’s Beard Butter – Best Overall
Wild Willie’s Beard Butter is our number one choice. This top-quality beard butter consists of 13 local organic ingredients and is produced in Georgia, USA. On top of that, it uses a special hand-blended formula to ensure top quality.
The list of ingredients contains shea butter, castor oil, sweet almond oil, argan oil, grape-seed oil, jojoba oil, tea tree oil, cedar-wood oil, rosemary extract, soybean oil, sunflower oil, beeswax, and Vitamin E.
This butter moisturizes your skin and prevents infections thanks to tea-tree oil. Cedarwood gives a nice refreshing scent with traces of rosemary. If you prefer a fresh minty scent, then you might want to try the alternative package. Wild Willie’s Beard Butter is also really good for styling your facial hair as it contains beeswax.
- 13 Local Ingredients
- Made in the USA
- Hand Blended Formula
- 100% Organic
- No GMOs
- Strong Scent For Some People
2. Detroit Grooming Co. Beard Butter – Best For Customization
This is another premium, high-quality beard butter that is formulated with 100% natural ingredients.
It has the following ingredients: Vitamin E Oil, Sweet almond oil, Avocado Oil, Apricot oil, Sunflower oil, unrefined shea butter, olive oil, coconut oil, and wheat germ oil.
With all these ingredients’ nourishing and moisturizing effects, you will not get dry skin again. Add to that all the organic carrier oils, and you get a spa-like treatment every time you apply it to your face.
What we also like about Detroit Grooming Co. Beard Butter is that it comes in six different scent combinations to satisfy all different tastes. There is also one variation of it that contains beeswax with great shaping power.
You can choose between a variety of scents like Orange & Vanilla scent, Cherry Tobacco, Sandalwood, Vanilla Tobacco & Cedarwood, Mango & Lime, and Cedarwood.
Detroit Grooming Beard Butter covers many different types of scents and comes with the guarantee of a high-quality product. This could be considered as the best choice for individuals that want a lot of customization options for their product.
- Made in USA
- 100% Natural Formula
- Lots of Scents
- High Quality and Cost Effective
- Somewhat Expensive
3. Maestro’s Classic Mark of a Man – Best Value
Maestro’s Classic Mark of a Man is another good choice for individuals looking for cost-effective, effective product.
It is advertised as a hydrating beard cream that will moisturize your facial hair and has been called ‘undeniably good’ by dozens of reviewers.
There are three different packaging sizes available, including packaging variations between 2 Oz. and 8 Oz. Maestro’s Classic Mark of a Man is specifically designed as a water-soluble hydrating cream that brings additional moisture to the skin on your face.
The high-quality blend includes a formula that utilizes natural ingredients like Grapefruit, Black Pepper, Bergamot, and more. After taking a closer look at the customer reviews for Maestro’s Classic Mark of a Man, we can say that it is overwhelmingly popular.
- Extremely Effective
- Water Based Formula
- Cost Effective Product
- Limited Scents
4. Fresh Beards “Classic” Beard Butter – Best New Entry
There are many highlights to the overall design of the Fresh Beards ‘Classic’ Beard Butter product. This shea-based product is specifically designed to be as natural as possible to provide users with the ultimate beard-grooming experience.
It does not contain potentially harmful ingredients like parabens, sulfates, or silicones. Instead, it is designed to keep your beard soft and reduce the negative side effects like beard itch and beard dandruff.
You should consider any of the variations that are currently available. It’s highly recommended to research each of the variations available before finalizing your purchase.
- Extremely Effective
- Many Variations Are Available
- Premium Design Blend
- Slightly Expensive
5. Grave Before Shave Cigar Blend Beard Butter – Best Scented
The fifth product that will be included in this section is the Grave Before Shave Cigar Blend Beard Butter. This premium beard butter comes in a 4 Oz. container; it has a special cigar-vanilla blended formula that only includes the best butters and oils available on the market.
You can purchase this cigar blend from Grave Before Shave to soften your beard and skin.
This premium blend can easily be applied to your facial hair by hand and will naturally dissolve as you apply it to the appropriate areas on your beard and skin.
- Deeply Softens Beard and Skin
- High-Quality Blend
- Cost Effective Product
- Limited Packaging Variations
6. Live Bearded Beard Butter -Best Lightweight Formula
Live bearded legend beard butter is a lightweight beard butter with a really nice and masculine scent of sandalwood and vanilla made from 100% natural ingredients.
Its key ingredients are coconut oil, shea butter, jojoba oil, sweet almond oil, and more. It has a creamy texture making it really easy to apply even for beginners.
Live bearded legend beard butter is made from 100% natural ingredients that will not weigh your beard down or grease it. It will hydrate and nourish your facial hair and skin all day long. It is highly recommended if you have dry skin.
- 100% Natural ingredients.
- Lightweight formula.
- Easy to apply
- Strong scent might not be for everyone
7. Beard Guys Beard Butter – Best Moisturizer
Beard Guyz beard butter updated its formula in 2020 based on its customers’ feedback. It is made from 100% natural ingredients and is designed to hydrate and leave your beard soft and moisturize your skin.
Some of the ingredients it contains are shea and mango butter, coconut oil, grapeseed oil, and keratin.
Beard Guyz butter will help you tame your unruly beard and, at the same time, make it look fuller. Based on its natural and moisturizing ingredients, it is a really good choice for a dry and itchy beard.
- Good moisturizer.
- Contains natural ingredients.
- Good for dry hair
- Not everyone likes the scent
All five of these products are highly reputable and could be the perfect choice for you. In this review, we have selected Wild Willie’s Beard Butter as our top overall choice because of the positive aspects developed into its formula.
Are you interested in learning more about each of these beard butter brands? If so, we highly recommend you check out each product by visiting the link to their product page. There are so many reasons to try these products, and you now have all the information you need to make the best possible decision for yourself.
Beard Butter FAQ
What kind of ingredients are in beard butters?
As we mentioned above, the butter used in beard butter brands is not the type of butter that you would use in everyday cooking. In most cases, various brands will use cocoa butter, shea butter, or mango butter as a part of their basic ingredients.
We have discussed carrier oils in our DIY beard oil guide in-depth, but let’s refresh some of their main properties and benefits here. Carrier oils can quickly penetrate your skin and moisturize it.
Especially when it comes to hair, carrier oils have the unique ability to penetrate sebaceous glands. These glands are responsible for the production of the necessary oils that keep your beard hydrated and healthy.
When your facial hair gets longer, sebaceous glands are unable to produce the necessary sebum oil your beard needs. This is where carrier oils can help. They have similar properties to sebum oil and keep your beard moisturized. Some of the most common and good carrier oils found in beard products are jojoba, avocado, grapeseed oil, and sweet almond oil.
Essential oils are responsible for the scent of beard butter, but some essential oils have other properties too.
Before we continue talking about essential oils, we have to advise you never to apply essential oils directly to your skin because they are very strong and may cause different types of irritation. Essential oils are always mixed with carrier oils for this reason.
And this is where it gets subjective because it depends on what kind of scent you like. As a general rule, it may not be a very good idea to go for something too strong, as you will apply it to facial hair that is close to your nose, and a strong smell might be disturbing for you.
Some of the most common scents include citrus, mango-lime, and cigar scent.
In addition, the main benefit of essential oils for your facial hair is that they have strong anti-microbe and antiseptic properties that will leave you with a healthy beard.
Beeswax is an ingredient that you will not always see in beard butter. It is used mainly as a binder but also acts as a protectant. Beeswax, especially in lower temperatures, can create a protective layer for your beard hair and help all the above ingredients to penetrate and unleash their nourishing properties.
What are the benefits of beard butters?
They are Non-Allergenic
According to research, there are no major allergic reactions related to the ingredients of these various brands of beard butter.
They Moisturize the Skin
Oleic, palmitic, and linoleic acids are the majority of the butter’s fatty acid content. These acids, when applied to the skin, create moisture and restore lipids.
Anti-oxidant and anti-inflammatory properties
Essential oils help to trigger the inflammatory shells in your skin. This leads to minimizing irritation caused by dry weather. All-natural beard butters containing essential oils will not only give you a nice scent but have several deep conditioning properties and treat your unruly hair from sticking out.
Thanks to the high levels of Vitamin E and A, they have high antioxidant properties. These vitamins help your skin cells and prevent some of the visual effects of aging. Some beard butters claim to stimulate beard growth (not backed by research), but they will provide you with the perfect combination of ingredients for a reasonable price.
They Help with Several Conditions by Utilizing Natural Ingredients
According to studies, these products can help as they moisturize the skin and prevent irritation. Some brands even offer a 100% Money-Back Guarantee if you are not satisfied.
One of the most common ingredients, cocoa butter, is extracted from cocoa beans (the same ones used for chocolate). After the beans are cleaned, they are roasted and finally pressed.
It is high in fatty acids that help with skin moisturization. It also has a high concentration of phytochemicals, which happens to be a substance that improves blood flow, and as a result, the healthy growth of your beard.
What Does Beard Butter Do?
After analyzing all the ingredients in beard butter, it is easy to understand the main effects.
Beard butter penetrates your skin cells and hair follicles and keeps them hydrated. It has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties and helps with skin irritation. As a bonus, it gives your beard a nice scent and can help to keep your skin healthy.
Beard Butter VS Beard Balm
A lot of beard-men, even fellow bloggers, have a difficult time distinguishing butter from beard balm. The truth is that these products are similar but there are some details that differentiate them.
The first and most obvious is that beard balm doesn’t contain butter while beard butter does. That makes sense, right? Unlike butter, beard balm contains wax in big concentrations, and while a lot of butters contain wax, it usually is in really small quantities. These are the main differences between the ingredients in these 2 products.
When it comes to when you should use each of them, as we mentioned above, beard balm is more of a styling product to help with stray hair, while beard butter is more of a nourishing product.
What is the difference between beard butter and beard oil?
Beard butter is more like a moisturizer and conditioner that will moisturize and hydrate your beard and help you with beard itch and irritation. On the other hand, beard oil is used to strengthen your beard and promote hair growth.
Does beard butter help in hair growth?
No, beard butter does not work wonders, but it helps maintain healthy skin and hair, making it easier. It will moisturize your skin, nourish your facial hair, and get rid of itchiness and irritation, especially if you have dry skin.
When should I use beard butter?
You should use beard butter after showering for several reasons. Firstly, your beard and skin will be clean, so you will not be rubbing all the germs and dirt on your face. And secondly, the pores of your skin and beard will be open, so it will be easier for the nourishing ingredients to penetrate.
How often should I use beard butter?
You can use beard butter as many times as you want throughout the day, depending on your skin type, but please don’t overdo it.
Our advice is to use it once a day, every morning, and let it protect your beard and nourish it throughout the day. If you use it more often, you risk getting your hair greasy, but again, it depends on your hair and skin type.
How to Use Beard Butter?
The process of using beard butter is identical to the one of beard balm, so if you have used beard balm in the past, you can skip this section. If not, keep reading.
- Wash your beard with a beard wash.
- Open the package and, with your finger, scoop it from one side to another.
- Put the butter you have scooped in your palm and rub your palms until it has become completely oily with no grains.
- Massage your beard and make sure you touch your fingers to your skin.
- Repeat if you haven’t added enough to cover all your beard (don’t overdo it).
- Brush your beard with a beard brush or a beard comb to make sure even distribution for a softer beard.
Russell is the founder of themensattitude.com. He is a barber a beard enthusiast and he is obsessed with trying men’s lifestyle products and blog about them. If you have any questions you can hit him up via the contact page.