Home » The Best Shaving Soap for a Manly Shave

The Best Shaving Soap for a Manly Shave

The Men’s Attitude is reader-supported! We might get a small commission if you purchase something after clicking our links, at no extra charge for you.

Many men choose a good shaving cream for their grooming process, but there is something that makes all the difference in a smooth shave, and that is shaving soap.

Shaving soaps moisturize and protect your skin during the shaving process, making them a highly valuable addition to your shaving routine.

Read more to find out what is the best shaving soap and how to choose one.

​A Quick Glance At The Top 3 Shaving Soaps

Sir Hare Shave Soap

Sir Hare Shaving Soap for Men

Sir Hare Shaving Soap for Men has everything you look for in a shaving soap. It has a nice lather and scent and leaves you with a smooth face. This is why it is our first choice.

The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap "Smolder"

The Blades Grim – Gold Luxury Shaving Soap “Smolder”

As the name implies, The Blades Grim is a luxury soap with rich, quick leather and a great scent. It is made from 100% natural ingredients making it a really good choice for men with sensitive skin.

Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shea Butter

Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shea Butter by Henry Cavendish

Henry Cavendish’s Himalaya Shaving Soap is a moisturizing shaving soap with a rich lather and a subtle soft smell. If you have dry or sensitive skin, the shea butter it contains will help you.

How to Choose a shaving Soap?

When searching for the best shaving soap, you should consider the following factors:


Some men like their soaps perfumed to add that special touch to their grooming routine, while others prefer them fragrant-free.

The answer to this question is based on a rather personal preference, and you are the only one that knows the answer.

Of course, some brands do a better job, but again it is subjective.

The Fat Content

In most things in everyday life, you try to stay away from the fat content, right?

But this is not true with your shaving soap.

A soap with glycerin or tallow is exactly what you are looking for. Glycerin and tallow make the lather you need for a safe and smooth shave. 

Remember to always look for the fat content in the soap and ensure you are getting a shaving soap with a high-fat concentration.

The Best Shaving Soaps On The Market

1. Sir Hare Shaving Soap for Men

Sir Hare Shave Soap

The Sir Hare Shaving Soap for Men is tallow based, an important feature in shaving soaps.

And is important because it provides the lather that ensures a safe and smooth shave.

Another plus is that it’s made from all-natural ingredients, which is ideal for men with sensitive skin.

It has a subtle scent of cedarwood and oakmoss, giving it a mild fragrance.


  • It smells good
  • It provides a good lather
  • It leaves your face feeling smooth


  • It takes time and knack to build a good lather
  • Some men prefer a stronger fragrance

2. Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shea Butter by Henry Cavendish

Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shea Butter

If you have sensitive or dry skin, the shea butter in the Henry Cavendish is a really good choice.

It contains moisturizing ingredients like shea butter and coconut oil that help to keep your skin moisturized and smooth.

With such a slight aroma, it’s a good choice for men who don’t like fragrances in their soaps.

It provides a rich lather which results in a smooth shave.


  • It has a soft subtle scent
  • It provides a rich lather
  • It includes moisturizing ingredients


  • It isn’t large, which means it doesn’t last as long as some others
  • It takes some effort to get the lather going

3. Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap

Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap

Col. Conk is a shaving soap that has avocado oil and vitamin E, making it a good choice for men with dry skin.

It has a subtle scent of Bay Rum that lasts for a long time, and it comes in a neat package that can be carried on trips.

While it may take some time for you to build a good lather, once you add enough water, it lathers up nicely for a smooth shave.

At an affordable price, it is a really good value-for-money choice.


  • The smell is subtle yet pleasant and lasts
  • It comes in convenient packaging
  • It is affordable


  • It doesn’t provide as thick a lather as some other soaps
  • It is a bit small and doesn’t last very long

4. Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl

propaso shaving soap

Proraso Shaving Soap in a bowl is a great example of classic shaving cream.

It produces a rich, creamy lather that is pleasant to work with and provides a clean shave without nicks or cuts to the skin.

Menthol and eucalyptus work together to provide a cooling sensation and purify and tone the skin underneath.

This concentrated soap is still made in small batches using a rigorous, time-tested process. 


  • Concentrated, creamy lather feels pleasant on the face
  • Eucalyptus tones and purifies the skin, while menthol refreshes and revitalizes it
  • A thick lather provides a clean shave without nicks or scratches


  • Lather loses potency over time.
  • The light scent might not be suitable for sensitive skin.

5. The Blades Grim – Gold Luxury Shaving Soap “Smolder”

The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap

As you would expect from a luxury soap, the Blades Grim soap offers a thick lather and a pleasant scent that is both manly and subtle.

If the winner for ” best shaving soap ” would be based just on the scent, this soap would be the reigning champion.

Made from 100% natural ingredients, the Blades Grim soap is a good choice for men with sensitive skin as it won’t irritate or cause inflammation.

The stylish packaging is both functional and attractive and is relatively inexpensive.


  • It lathers thickly and quickly
  • It smells great
  • It is ideal for sensitive skin


  • Once it lathers, men have to shave right away as it dries quickly
  • The great smell goes away somewhat quickly

The Best Shaving SoapThe Best Shaving Soap

The Winner Is…

While we like every shaving soap we have mentioned, and each has its pros that make them reliable purchases, our favorite and winner is the Sir Hare Shaving Soap for Men.

It combines the ideal features and allows you to get the smooth and soft shave you are looking for.

It has a nice scent and great lather and leaves you with that smooth feeling at an affordable price.

Shaving Soap FAQ

Is Shaving Soap Good for Sensitive Skin?

You need to make sure to get a shaving soap that won’t irritate you if you have sensitive skin.

Shaving soap is a better choice than shaving cream or shaving gel if you have sensitive skin, as it provides a moisturizing lather which is very important. Here you can check the best shaving creams and the best shaving gels.

You should look at the ingredients and choose a shaving soap with special ingredients, such as lavender or any other natural ingredient that is beneficial for sensitive skin.

Is Shaving Soap Good For Dry Skin?

If you have dry skin, you need to look for soaps that have special oils or butter that will moisturize your skin and leave you with bump-free and soft skin.

The percentage of fat content in most shaving soaps makes a more oil-like lather than a shaving cream which benefits your dry skin and leaves you with a soft, smooth face. 

What Ingredients should you look for?

While there are many different ingredients found in shaving soaps, the ones you want to look for to ensure you get soft skin are:

  • Mango
  • Lanolin
  • Lavender
  • Aloe
  • Coconut Oil
  • Castor Oil
  • Shea Butter
  • Avocado Oil
  • Vitamins

These above-mentioned ingredients are extremely helpful. 

Of course, you are not going to find a soap that contains all of them, but depending on your shaving goals and needs, make sure to choose a soap that contains at least one.

Best Ingredients for Shaving Soap

Why Is Shaving Soap Better Than Shaving Cream?

If you have been using shaving cream for years, you may wonder why you should start using a shaving soap.

Here are some benefits you will get from using shaving soap:

  • It’s probably what your great-grandfather used to shave, which is pretty cool and kind of proves that maybe there’s something to it.
  • Shaving soap contains ingredients that are key for lubrication and will keep your skin free of bumps and inflammation.
  • Shaving soap is more affordable than shaving cream and usually lasts longer, making it more cost-effective.
  • The lather you can make with quality shaving soap is much better than the one with shaving cream. While you do have to do a little work to build a rich lather, the result will be worth it once you do. A good shaving soap will provide you with the moisture and lather that will make your razor glide effortlessly. If you don’t know what type of razor you should use. Read our best razor for men review, the best straight razor review, and the best safety razor review.

Whether you have used shaving soap before or you are reading about it for the first time, it’s worth giving it a try, especially if your skin gets irritated and doesn’t feel smooth after a shave.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *